The official student news site of Algonquin Regional High School in Northborough, MA

Debate: Should there be required summer reading?

Yes! Uniform reading starts students on the same page

October 2, 2016

Leaving school for a two month period allows for students to take a break from all of the hard work and nightly homework assignments. This naturally leads to both students and teachers getting a little rusty.

Summer reading is a fun and easy way to keep yourself on track for the following school year.
Summer reading has a great idea behind it. In addition to keeping reading and critical thinking skills in practice, summer reading provides people to look at different ideas. Summer reading provides the opportunity to experience a written work not just as an individual, but as a student body. It allows people to see and learn that there will be many perspectives or interpretations by different readers. We should be open to hearing what each of these may be and even adopting some of these opinions .

Reading one book as a whole school opens up the chance to perhaps understand your peers while discussing challenging topics, and even to learn something new about someone as you share feedback about the story. Summer reading allows for a quick and easy jump back into the school year. It not only helps getting used to the work load, but it also allows people to quickly begin relationships within the classroom.

We can grow as individuals and as a student body when we open ourselves up to sharing, discussing, and learning as a group. There is no better way to start the school year than on the same page as everyone else.

Debate: Should there be required summer reading?

No! Reading requirement adds useless stress

It’s the first day of summer. All the recently released students twiddle their thumbs and rack their brains on what they could possibly be expected to do with all their free time over the next two months. But then, they remember the one solution to their problem; they have summer reading! Hightailing it to the nearest book store, their nerves subside as they get their hands on the one thing that will maintain their desire to succeed when the they return to school in the fall.

Though this scenario may be what teachers dream of happening, it is far from realistic. Many students don’t even pick up the summer reading book once over the course of their time-off. The idea of unity that is so highly emphasized with ‘One School, One Book’ isn’t even practiced. Requiring the entire school to read the same book is pointless when only a fraction of the students actually read it.

When students do actually read it, there is a good chance that their English teacher won’t even incorporate the book into their curriculum. What is the point of dedicating the time to read the book when that time is sometimes not even acknowledged?

The whole process of summer reading interferes with the pleasure that should be associated with reading a book. Perhaps an alternative to an assigned novel would be encouraging students to choose a book that specifically appeals to their interests. This would still allow students to maintain their intellectual abilities over the break, which apparently will disappear if not stimulated by a book.

Students already have countless things keeping them busy during the summer; whether it includes travel, a job, homework, or preparing for the college search. These activities all require extensive time commitments and responsibility; introducing summer reading to this mix creates even more stress. Minimizing the number of burdens that the students face during the summer will only make them more productive in other aspects of their lives.

Leave a Comment
Donate to THE ALGONQUIN HARBINGER
$1580
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal

A donation of $40 or more includes a subscription to the 2024-25 print issues of The Harbinger. We will mail a copy of our fall, winter, spring and graduation issues to the recipient of your choice. Your donation supports the student journalists of Algonquin Regional High School and allows our extracurricular publication to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

About the Writers
Photo of Shannon Youngberg
Shannon Youngberg, News Editor

Shannon joined the Harbinger during her Sophomore year in 2014 after taking a Journalism class and discovered that she had a knack for news writing. She...

Donate to THE ALGONQUIN HARBINGER
$1580
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal